Annapolis Erb’s Palsy Attorney
Erb’s palsy is one of the few birth injuries that sounds like a purely physical accident of delivery, yet in many cases it traces back to decisions made in the minutes before and during a baby’s shoulders emerged. D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC represents families in Annapolis, Anne Arundel County, and throughout Maryland and Washington, D.C. when a Annapolis Erb’s palsy attorney is needed to examine whether a delivery team’s choices caused a brachial plexus injury to a newborn.
The injury involves the network of nerves running from the spinal cord through the neck and into the shoulder, arm, and hand. When those nerves are stretched, torn, or pulled from the spinal cord during delivery, an infant may be born with an arm that hangs limp, a hand that curls inward, or little ability to lift the affected shoulder. Some babies recover function over months of therapy. Others need nerve surgery, and some are left with permanent weakness, limited range of motion, or a shorter, thinner arm. The question that decides whether a legal claim exists is not simply whether the injury happened, but whether a provider’s departure from accepted obstetric care caused it.
That distinction matters because providers often defend these cases by saying the nerve damage came from natural forces of labor rather than from traction applied by a clinician. Whether that defense holds up depends on records, fetal monitoring data, delivery notes, and testimony from qualified specialists. Families deciding what to do next are weighing a medical diagnosis, a recovery timeline for their child, and a legal clock that begins running in ways many parents do not expect.
What Causes Brachial Plexus Injuries During Delivery
The most common setting for Erb’s palsy is shoulder dystocia, where the baby’s head delivers but the shoulder lodges behind the mother’s pubic bone. Shoulder dystocia is an obstetric emergency, and it can occur without anyone doing anything wrong. The legal question is how the team responded. Accepted maneuvers exist to free the shoulder, and excessive downward or lateral traction on the baby’s head, particularly when the neck is bent away from the shoulder, can place severe strain on the nerves.
Risk factors are often visible before delivery. A large baby, maternal diabetes, a prior shoulder dystocia, a prolonged pushing stage, and an assisted delivery with a vacuum extractor or forceps all raise the likelihood of trouble. A provider who recognizes those risks has choices: recommending a cesarean delivery, counseling the mother about the risk, or preparing the team and the room in advance. When a chart shows the risk factors were present and nothing was done to plan for them, that gap often becomes the center of the case.
Why Choose D’Amore Personal Injury Law for an Erb’s Palsy Claim
D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC is a trial firm that handles medical malpractice, birth injury, cerebral palsy, traumatic brain injury, spine injury, and other catastrophic injury claims for families in Annapolis and Anne Arundel County, across Baltimore City and Baltimore County, in Prince George’s and Montgomery Counties, and in Washington, D.C. The firm has recovered more than $150 million for injured clients and their families. Clients have direct access to their attorney from start to finish, the firm advances all case costs, and there is no fee unless the case is won. A free case evaluation is available, and the firm is reachable around the clock.
Paul D’Amore, the firm’s Founding Member and trial lawyer, has more than 25 years of trial experience. He spent the first decade of his career defending hospitals, physicians, and insurance companies, which means he has sat on the other side of cases like this one. He knows how a hospital’s lawyers will frame a shoulder dystocia, which experts they tend to retain, and where the “natural forces of labor” argument is vulnerable. That perspective shapes how each case is built from the first records request forward. Paul has been recognized by Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, The National Trial Lawyers Top 100, America’s Top 100 High Stakes Litigators, and Distinguished Justice Advocates.
The firm’s birth injury record includes a $6.9 million recovery for a family whose baby was catastrophically injured at a major Maryland hospital and a $6 million recovery for a child who suffered a devastating brain injury after serious medical complications. It has also secured a $4.26 million jury verdict in Baltimore City Circuit Court in a malpractice case where the defense offered nothing before trial, which reflects a willingness to try a case rather than accept an inadequate number. Clients describe the firm as empathetic, attentive to detail, and willing to take cases other firms turned away.
Situations Where an Erb’s Palsy Claim May Exist
- Shoulder Dystocia Mismanagement: Delivery notes that describe heavy traction, a prolonged interval between delivery of the head and the body, or failure to use recognized maneuvers to release the shoulder can point to a departure from the standard of care.
- Ignored Macrosomia Risk: When an ultrasound or fundal height suggested a large baby and the mother was never offered a cesarean or counseled on the risk, the planning failure may be as significant as the delivery itself.
- Maternal Diabetes Not Accounted For: Gestational or pre-existing diabetes increases fetal size and shoulder dystocia risk, and prenatal records should show that the delivery plan reflected it.
- Assisted Delivery Errors: Improper use of a vacuum extractor or forceps, or continued attempts after they failed to produce progress, can contribute to nerve stretching and avulsion.
- Delayed Cesarean Decisions: A stalled labor, a descent that stopped, or a history of prior shoulder dystocia may call for a cesarean that was not performed.
- Failure to Diagnose and Refer Early: After birth, a baby with a limp arm needs prompt evaluation and referral to a pediatric specialist, and delays in that follow-up can affect the child’s recovery.
- Associated Injuries: Clavicle fractures, humerus fractures, Horner’s syndrome, and phrenic nerve injury sometimes accompany brachial plexus damage and help reconstruct what forces were applied.
Decisions Parents Face in the First Months After Diagnosis
Parents of a baby with a brachial plexus injury are usually managing therapy appointments, specialist referrals, and a great deal of uncertainty about how much function will return. The legal decisions run alongside that, and a few of them are time-sensitive. The first is requesting the complete records, both the mother’s prenatal and labor chart and the baby’s newborn and neonatal records, including the electronic fetal monitoring strips. Hospitals can be slow to produce them, and a claim cannot be evaluated without them.
The second decision is whether to wait and see how the child recovers before consulting a lawyer. Waiting feels reasonable, since many infants improve. But the evidence in these cases is perishable, memories fade, and the legal deadlines do not pause for a recovery curve. A consultation does not commit a family to filing anything. It allows a medical review to begin while the records are fresh, and it gives parents a clear picture of whether a viable claim exists.
The third decision concerns documentation outside the hospital chart. Parents should keep a record of therapy visits, photographs and video showing the child’s arm movement over time, referrals to pediatric neurology, orthopedics, or nerve surgery, and out-of-pocket costs for equipment and travel. Avoid discussing fault in detail with the hospital’s risk management staff or signing anything an insurer sends without having it reviewed. A hospital representative who calls to express concern is also gathering information for the defense.
How Maryland Law Shapes an Erb’s Palsy Case
Maryland medical malpractice claims against a health care provider must be filed within the earlier of five years from when the injury was committed or three years from when it was discovered. When the injured patient is a child, the deadline for the child’s own claim generally does not start running until age 18, but a parent’s claim for the child’s medical bills is on a shorter clock. That rule can give families more time than the general deadlines suggest, but relying on it is risky because the parents’ own claims, including their medical expenses, are not necessarily treated the same way, and evidence deteriorates long before any deadline expires.
Maryland also requires that malpractice claims begin at the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office in Baltimore. Filing there counts as filing the lawsuit for deadline purposes. The claimant must file a certificate from a qualified medical expert within 90 days of the complaint, stating that the provider breached the standard of care and that the breach caused the injury, or the claim is dismissed without prejudice. The statute allows an extension for good cause, and no certificate is required if the defendant does not dispute liability. The expert who signs it cannot have devoted more than 25 percent of professional activities in the prior 12 months to testifying in personal injury claims. Parties may waive arbitration, and the case is then transferred to circuit court, which is where jury trials occur. For Annapolis families, that is the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, which sits in Annapolis.
Damages in these cases fall into two categories. Economic damages, which include the cost of surgeries, therapy, equipment, and the loss of future earning capacity if a child’s arm function is permanently limited, are not capped in Maryland. Noneconomic damages such as pain, suffering, and physical impairment are capped in malpractice cases, with the cap set by the year the injury occurred and increasing each January 1. The jury is not told about the limit. Because the cap is fixed, the economic side of a brachial plexus claim, built through life care planning and vocational and economic experts, often determines the real value of the case.
Maryland also follows contributory negligence, which bars recovery from a plaintiff whose own negligence contributed to the harm. In a birth injury case, the injured child is not at fault, but defense teams sometimes try to point at the mother’s conduct, such as missed appointments or declined interventions. A thorough review of the prenatal chart anticipates that argument.
Proving the Case: Medical Evidence in Brachial Plexus Claims
Brachial plexus cases are won on the medical detail. The delivery record should show the time between the head and the body, which maneuvers were used and in what order, and who was in the room. Fetal monitoring strips show whether the baby was already showing signs of distress. The newborn exam documents the arm’s presentation, and later nerve studies and imaging help define whether the nerves were stretched, ruptured, or avulsed from the spinal cord, which matters for both prognosis and causation.
The firm consults obstetricians, maternal-fetal medicine specialists, pediatric neurologists, and nerve surgeons, and builds the future-care picture with life care planners. Defense experts commonly argue that maternal expulsive forces alone can cause the injury. Answering that requires specifics: the pattern of injury, the documented traction, and whether the baby’s size and risk profile made the outcome foreseeable and avoidable.
Questions About Erb’s Palsy Claims in Annapolis
What is Erb’s palsy?
It is a form of brachial plexus injury affecting the upper nerves that control the shoulder and arm. Affected infants may be unable to raise the arm, bend the elbow, or move the shoulder normally, and the hand may be weak or curled.
Does every case of Erb’s palsy mean a doctor was negligent?
No. Some brachial plexus injuries occur even when delivery is handled properly. A claim exists only when evidence shows a provider departed from accepted care and that departure caused the injury, which is why a records and expert review comes before any decision to file.
How long do I have to file in Maryland?
The general limit is the earlier of five years from the injury or three years from its discovery. A child’s own malpractice claim in Maryland can generally be brought until three years after the child turns 18, while a parent’s claim for the child’s medical expenses has an earlier deadline. Because filing with the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office counts as filing the case, that is the date that matters.
Do I need a medical expert before I can file?
Yes, in most cases. A certificate from a qualified expert must be filed within 90 days of the complaint, or the claim is dismissed without prejudice. Courts must grant an extension for good cause, and no certificate is required if the defendant does not dispute liability.
Will my child’s arm recover on its own?
Many infants improve substantially, and some regain nearly full function. Others have lasting weakness or need surgery. Pediatric specialists typically track progress over the first months, and the long-term outlook shapes the value of a claim.
Is there a limit on what a Maryland family can recover?
Noneconomic damages in malpractice cases are capped, and the cap depends on the year of injury. Economic damages, including future medical care and lost earning capacity, are not capped. Punitive damages are not limited by the general cap either, though they are rarely available.
Can I bring a claim if the delivery happened at a hospital in Washington, D.C.?
Yes. The firm practices in both jurisdictions. The District does not cap malpractice damages and generally applies a three-year limit, but it requires a written notice of intent to the provider at least 90 days before suit. Those cases are heard in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, where court-ordered mediation is required.
What if the hospital says the injury was caused by the mother’s pushing?
That is a common defense, often called maternal forces of labor. Rebutting it depends on the injury pattern, the documented traction, fetal size, and expert analysis of whether clinician force was the more likely cause.
Can parents recover their own costs, not just the child’s?
Medical expenses incurred during the child’s minority are typically a claim belonging to the parents, while the child’s own claim covers future care, impairment, and lost earning capacity. How these are structured affects deadlines, so it should be reviewed early.
Is it worth pursuing a claim if my baby’s injury seems mild?
It can be. Mild-appearing injuries sometimes lead to permanent limits in strength or reach that become more evident as a child grows and takes on sports or manual tasks. A review will not commit you to filing, and it clarifies whether the evidence supports a claim worth the cost of litigation.
What does it cost to hire the firm?
The firm advances all case costs, and there is no fee unless the case is won. The initial evaluation is free.
Serving Erb’s Palsy Families Across Annapolis and Maryland
The firm’s work for Annapolis families begins in Anne Arundel County and extends outward. Clients come from Annapolis itself and the surrounding communities of Edgewater, Severna Park, Arnold, Crofton, Odenton, Glen Burnie, Pasadena, Millersville, Davidsonville, Gambrills, and Linthicum. Families from Baltimore City and Baltimore County, including Towson, Dundalk, Catonsville, and Owings Mills, also turn to the firm, as do families in Prince George’s County and Montgomery County and across Washington, D.C.
Birth injury cases often involve the region’s major hospitals. The firm has handled claims involving institutions in Baltimore, including Johns Hopkins Hospital, University of Maryland Medical Center, Mercy Medical Center, Sinai Hospital, and Greater Baltimore Medical Center, along with Anne Arundel Medical Center and, in the District, Children’s National, Georgetown University Medical Center, and Washington Hospital Center. A child injured at any of them may be treated across several systems, and the firm coordinates records and experts across all of them.
Speak With an Annapolis Erb’s Palsy Lawyer
If your child was born with a brachial plexus injury and you want to know whether the delivery team’s choices played a part, an Annapolis Erb’s palsy lawyer at D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC can review the records and explain what the evidence shows. The consultation is free, you will speak directly with your attorney, and you will owe no fee unless the firm wins your case. Call today to talk through what happened and what your family’s options are.
