Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu

Baltimore Erb’s Palsy Attorney

Families in Baltimore who have just been told their newborn cannot move one arm are usually given very little explanation, and they are expected to decide quickly whether this was an unavoidable event or a mistake in the delivery room. D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC handles medical malpractice and birth injury claims for patients and families in Baltimore, Annapolis, Washington, D.C., and communities across Maryland, and the firm approaches a Baltimore Erb’s palsy attorney engagement as a question of what the delivery team did, what it should have done, and what that child will need for the rest of life.

Erb’s palsy is an injury to the brachial plexus, the bundle of nerves running from the neck into the shoulder and arm. It most often shows up after a shoulder dystocia, when a baby’s shoulder lodges behind the mother’s pelvic bone during delivery and the clinician pulls on the head to free it. Some of these injuries heal on their own over months. Others leave permanent weakness, limited range of motion, a shortened or smaller arm, or nerve damage that requires surgery. Whether a case exists at all depends on the labor and delivery record, not on the diagnosis alone.

That distinction matters because shoulder dystocia can occasionally happen despite excellent care, and hospitals and their insurers say so in nearly every defended case. A claim succeeds when the records show something that should have been recognized earlier or handled differently: a large baby whose size was known or should have been, a maternal diabetes risk that was not factored into the delivery plan, excessive traction, a failure to use recognized maneuvers, or an instrument-assisted delivery that went forward when a cesarean section was the safer route.

What Makes an Erb’s Palsy Case Provable Rather Than Merely Sad

The central dispute in almost every brachial plexus case is causation. The defense will argue that the baby’s own descent through the birth canal, or the mother’s contractions, stretched the nerves without any clinician force at all. This is sometimes called the “maternal forces of labor” theory, and answering it takes more than sympathy. It takes obstetric, neonatal, and biomechanical expert opinion, fetal monitoring strips, the shoulder dystocia documentation, and a careful timeline of how many minutes passed between the head delivering and the body delivering.

Paul D’Amore spent the first decade of his career defending hospitals, physicians, and insurance companies, which means he has seen how these defenses are assembled and where they weaken. In a case like this, that experience shapes the first questions asked of the chart. Was the estimated fetal weight discussed before delivery? Was the mother’s glucose history acknowledged? Was a second provider called when the dystocia began? Does the delivery note describe the maneuvers actually used, and does it match what nurses recorded? Gaps and contradictions between those documents are often where a claim is won.

Medical malpractice in the delivery room is also frequently documented in ways families never see. The baby’s hospital chart, the mother’s separate chart, the nursing notes, and the monitoring data all tell different parts of the story, and obtaining all of them is the first practical task of any investigation. We obtain the full records, have them reviewed by physicians in the relevant specialties, and reconstruct the delivery minute by minute before anyone decides whether to proceed.

Why Choose D’Amore Personal Injury Law for a Brachial Plexus Birth Injury

D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC is a Baltimore medical malpractice and personal injury firm led by Paul D’Amore, Founding Member and Trial Lawyer, who brings more than 25 years of trial experience to every case. The firm represents injured patients and families in Baltimore City and Baltimore County, Annapolis and Anne Arundel County, Prince George’s and Montgomery Counties, and Washington, D.C. It has recovered more than $150 million for clients, advances all case costs, and charges no fee unless it wins. Clients have direct access to their attorney from start to finish, and the firm is available around the clock.

For a family weighing an Erb’s palsy claim, the relevant proof is in the birth injury and catastrophic injury results. The firm secured $6.9 million for a family whose baby was catastrophically injured at a major Maryland hospital, and $6 million for a child with a devastating brain injury in a separate birth injury case. It also recovered $6 million for a young girl who suffered a preventable cardiac arrest in the ICU, and obtained a $4.26 million jury verdict in Baltimore City Circuit Court in a malpractice case where the defense had offered nothing before trial. Those outcomes reflect the firm’s willingness to try cases that insurers decline to value fairly. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any other matter.

Paul D’Amore has been recognized by Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, The National Trial Lawyers Top 100, America’s Top 100 High Stakes Litigators, and Distinguished Justice Advocates. Clients describe the firm as attentive, kind, and thorough, and one client noted the firm took the case when no one else would. Families often arrive after being told by other lawyers that a nerve injury case is too hard to prove, and the firm takes the time to explain the medical issues in plain language and give an honest read on the strength of a claim.

Situations That Lead to Brachial Plexus Injuries at Birth

  • Shoulder Dystocia Mishandled: The baby’s head delivers but the shoulder will not follow. Recognized maneuvers exist for this emergency, and claims arise when clinicians pull forcefully on the head or neck instead, or fail to document and escalate when the dystocia begins.
  • Fetal Macrosomia Not Planned For: Large babies are at higher risk of shoulder dystocia. When ultrasound or exam findings suggested a big baby and no one discussed a cesarean, that gap in planning can become central to the claim.
  • Maternal Diabetes or Gestational Diabetes: Poorly controlled blood sugar is associated with larger babies and a higher dystocia risk. A chart showing diabetes known during pregnancy but ignored at delivery raises serious questions.
  • Vacuum or Forceps Delivery: Instrument-assisted deliveries add traction to the head and can contribute to nerve injury, especially when used in a delivery already at risk for shoulder trouble or after prolonged labor.
  • Delayed or Prolonged Labor Management: A labor that stalls, a prolonged second stage, or failure to move to cesarean after poor progress can place mother and baby in a position where a hard delivery becomes likelier.
  • Breech and Abnormal Presentations: Difficult deliveries involving an unusual fetal position carry added risk to the nerves of the arm and shoulder.
  • Failure to Recognize Related Injuries: A baby with a fractured collarbone or humerus after delivery may also have nerve injury. Delayed neonatal evaluation or referral can worsen long-term function.
  • Missed Follow-Up Care: Brachial plexus injuries benefit from early therapy and sometimes early surgical evaluation. Delays in referral can affect how much function a child recovers.

What Baltimore Families Should Do After an Erb’s Palsy Diagnosis

Start by securing the records while the memory of the delivery is fresh. Request the complete labor and delivery chart for the mother and the full newborn chart for the baby, including fetal monitoring strips, nursing notes, anesthesia records, and any shoulder dystocia documentation. Hospitals in the Baltimore area, including the academic medical centers and community hospitals that serve the region, maintain these records, and families are entitled to request them. Write down what you remember: who was in the room, how long pushing lasted, whether the doctor called for help, what you heard said during the delivery, and when someone first mentioned the baby’s arm.

Follow every medical recommendation for your child, including pediatric neurology, occupational therapy, and any referral to a specialist in brachial plexus injuries. Early therapy matters for the child’s recovery, and it also creates a documented record of the injury’s progression. Keep photographs and video showing how the arm moves, along with receipts and mileage for appointments and equipment. Avoid giving recorded statements to the hospital’s risk management staff or its insurer without speaking to counsel first.

Maryland has a distinctive procedure for malpractice claims. A claim against a health care provider is first filed with the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office, and the claimant must file a certificate from a qualified medical expert within 90 days of the complaint, stating that the provider departed from the standard of care and that the departure caused the injury. A claim without that certificate is dismissed without prejudice, though the law requires an extension to be granted for good cause. The expert cannot be a professional witness, as the statute limits how much of an expert’s professional activity may involve testifying in personal injury claims. The parties can waive arbitration at that office and move the case to circuit court, where juries sit, which is how most serious cases proceed. For a Baltimore family, that is typically the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, though the right venue depends on where the claim arises and who is sued.

Timing is more forgiving for children than adults, but it should never be assumed. Under Maryland law, a malpractice claim must generally be filed within the earlier of five years from the injury or three years from its discovery. A child’s own malpractice claim in Maryland can generally be brought until three years after the child turns 18, while a parent’s claim for the child’s medical expenses has an earlier deadline. Even so, evidence disappears, witnesses move, and records are lost, so early investigation protects the claim regardless of how much legal time remains. If the delivery happened in Washington, D.C., a different rule applies: the District requires written notice of intent to the provider at least 90 days before a lawsuit, and its general three-year limitations period applies with a discovery rule. Court-ordered mediation is required in D.C. medical malpractice cases after filing.

How Damages Work When a Child Has a Permanent Arm Injury

The value of an Erb’s palsy claim depends on how much function the child recovers. A baby whose nerves regenerate fully may have limited damages, while a child left with a weak, shortened, or nonfunctional arm faces decades of therapy, possible nerve grafts or tendon transfers, adaptive equipment, reduced earning capacity, and the daily limitations of living with one arm that does not do what it should. Life care planners, pediatric orthopedists, vocational experts, and economists translate those realities into a figure for future medical care and lost earning capacity.

Maryland caps noneconomic damages, such as pain, suffering, and disfigurement, in medical malpractice cases. The cap is set by the year the injury occurred and increases by a fixed amount each January 1, and the jury is not told about it. Economic damages, including medical expenses, future care, therapy, surgery, and lost income, are not capped. That is why careful documentation of a child’s lifetime needs carries so much weight, and why a thin damages case undervalues a claim far more than the cap does. Washington, D.C. does not cap malpractice damages.

Maryland also follows contributory negligence in ordinary injury cases, which can bar recovery for a plaintiff who contributed to the harm. In a birth injury claim the baby cannot be at fault, but defendants sometimes try to shift attention to the mother’s conduct, such as prenatal care attendance or diabetes management. Anticipating that argument and answering it with the prenatal record is part of preparing the case.

Questions Families Ask About Erb’s Palsy Claims

Does every Erb’s palsy case involve medical malpractice?

No. Brachial plexus injuries can occur even when the delivery team acts appropriately, and the diagnosis alone does not establish negligence. A claim depends on whether the records and expert review show a departure from accepted obstetric practice that caused the injury.

What is the difference between Erb’s palsy and a brachial plexus injury?

Erb’s palsy is the most common pattern of brachial plexus injury, involving the upper nerves and typically affecting the shoulder and upper arm. Injuries to the lower nerves, or to the whole plexus, are more severe and may affect the hand as well. The medical team will classify the injury, and that classification influences the prognosis and the damages.

My baby’s arm is improving. Should I still talk to a lawyer?

It is reasonable to do so, because early recovery does not always continue and some children plateau with lasting deficits. Gathering records and getting an expert opinion early does not commit you to a lawsuit, and it preserves evidence while you watch how your child develops.

How long do I have to bring a claim in Maryland?

The general rule is the earlier of five years from the injury or three years from its discovery. For a child, Maryland courts have held that the time limit for the child’s own claim generally does not begin until the child turns 18, although a parent’s claim for medical expenses can face an earlier deadline. Because investigation takes time and the defense will test every date, families should not wait for the outer limits.

What is the certificate of a qualified expert?

It is a written statement from a qualified medical expert that the provider breached the standard of care and caused the injury. It must be filed within 90 days of the complaint or the claim is dismissed without prejudice, though the court must extend the time for good cause shown. It is not required if the defendant does not dispute liability.

Can I sue the doctor, the hospital, or both?

Either or both may be responsible. Obstetricians, midwives, nurses, and the hospital itself can each carry liability depending on who made the decisions and who employed them. Identifying the right defendants requires the full chart and a clear picture of who was involved in the delivery.

Does the cap on pain and suffering apply to a child’s injury?

Yes, Maryland’s malpractice cap on noneconomic damages applies regardless of the plaintiff’s age, and it is set by the year the injury occurred. The cap does not limit economic damages such as lifetime medical care, surgery, therapy, and lost earning capacity, which often make up the largest share of a serious birth injury claim.

Will the hospital’s insurer make a fair offer early?

Insurers often offer little or nothing before they see that a case is being prepared for trial. The firm’s $4.26 million Baltimore City Circuit Court verdict came in a case where the defense had offered nothing before trial. Preparation, not early goodwill, is what changes how a claim is valued.

What if the delivery took place in Washington, D.C.?

Different procedures apply. The District requires written notice of intent to sue at least 90 days before filing, applies a general three-year limitations period with a discovery rule, and requires court-ordered mediation after filing. It has no caps on damages. Because the firm practices in both Maryland and D.C., it can determine which rules govern.

Could my child need surgery, and does the claim cover it?

Some children with severe injuries undergo nerve grafts, nerve transfers, or tendon and muscle procedures, sometimes in infancy and sometimes later. Past and future surgical costs, along with rehabilitation and equipment, are part of economic damages and are not capped in Maryland.

Will pursuing a claim affect my child’s medical care?

No. A claim is separate from treatment, and your child’s providers should continue to treat the injury on its medical merits. Continuing care also builds the record that supports the claim.

Serving Baltimore Erb’s Palsy Families and the Surrounding Region

The firm represents families across Baltimore City, from Canton, Fells Point, Federal Hill, and Harbor East to Mount Vernon, Hampden, Roland Park, Highlandtown, and the neighborhoods of West and Northeast Baltimore. In Baltimore County it serves Towson, Dundalk, Essex, Catonsville, Pikesville, Owings Mills, Parkville, Randallstown, and Cockeysville. Families from Annapolis and across Anne Arundel County, including Glen Burnie, Severna Park, Odenton, and Crofton, come to the firm, as do families from Prince George’s County communities such as Bowie, Laurel, Hyattsville, and Upper Marlboro, and from Montgomery County including Bethesda, Silver Spring, Rockville, and Gaithersburg. The firm also represents patients and families in Washington, D.C., and handles birth injury claims involving the hospitals that deliver babies across the Baltimore, Annapolis, and D.C. regions.

Speak With a Baltimore Erb’s Palsy Lawyer About Your Child’s Delivery

If your child was diagnosed with Erb’s palsy or another brachial plexus injury after delivery, a conversation with a Baltimore Erb’s palsy lawyer can tell you whether the records support a claim and what the next steps look like. The evaluation is free, the firm advances all case costs, and there is no fee unless it wins. Call D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC any time, day or night, to speak directly with the legal team about what happened and what your child may need.

Free Case Evaluation Contact Us

If you or a loved one has been injured by someone else’s negligence, contact us immediately.

* Required

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC., through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms
Baltimore, MD Office

145 W Ostend St, Suite 600
Baltimore, MD 21230

Local: 410-324-2000

Fax: 443-782-0700

Washington, D.C. Office

1200 G Street NW, 8th Floor
Washington, D.C. 20005

Local: 202-780-9000

Fax: 443-782-0700