Washington DC Retained Surgical Object Attorney
A sponge, clamp, or needle left inside the body after an operation is one of the few surgical errors that is usually visible on a single scan, yet patients often live with pain, fever, or infection for weeks or years before anyone connects it to the original procedure. D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC represents patients and families harmed by medical malpractice in Washington, D.C., Baltimore, Annapolis, and communities throughout Maryland, and a Washington DC retained surgical object attorney from our firm approaches these cases with a clear view of how hospitals and their insurers respond when an item is found where it should never have been.
The medicine behind these cases is usually not in dispute. An X-ray, CT scan, or repeat operation shows the object, and the operative record shows what was counted. The real fight is over the details: whether the surgical team’s counts were documented correctly, who closed the incision knowing a count was off, how much harm the object caused during the time it stayed in the body, and what that harm will cost over a lifetime. Those questions decide the value of a claim, and they are where the defense concentrates its effort.
Retained objects are not limited to sponges. Cases involve surgical instruments, needles, pieces of broken equipment, guidewires, catheters, and drain components. Some objects set off infection or abscess formation. Others migrate, erode into the bowel or bladder, or cause obstructions that require major corrective surgery. A patient may go through a second operation just to remove what the first one left behind, and that second procedure carries its own risks.
Why Choose D’Amore Personal Injury Law for a Retained Surgical Object Claim
D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC is a trial firm that represents injured patients in Washington, D.C. and Maryland, including Baltimore City and Baltimore County, Annapolis and Anne Arundel County, and Prince George’s and Montgomery Counties. Founding attorney Paul D’Amore, a trial lawyer with more than 25 years of experience, spent the first decade of his career defending hospitals, physicians, and insurance companies. He knows how a hospital’s risk managers and defense experts evaluate a retained object case, what they look for in the count sheets and nursing notes, and where their explanations tend to fall apart. Clients get direct access to their attorney from start to finish, the firm advances all case costs, and there is no fee unless the firm wins. We are available 24/7, and the case evaluation is free.
The firm has recovered more than $150 million for clients, and its results come from precisely the kind of surgical negligence at issue in these claims. That includes $12.5 million for a client who suffered a permanent brain injury after surgeons lost control of bleeding during abdominal surgery, and $4.5 million for a father of two who lost the use of his arms and legs after neck surgery. It also includes a $4.26 million jury verdict in Baltimore City Circuit Court in a medical malpractice case where the defense offered nothing before trial. Paul D’Amore has been recognized by Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, The National Trial Lawyers Top 100, America’s Top 100 High Stakes Litigators, and Distinguished Justice Advocates.
Clients have described the firm as empathetic, attentive to detail, and willing to take cases other lawyers turned down. Our firm has pursued claims involving Children’s National, Georgetown University Medical Center, Sibley Memorial Hospital, and Washington Hospital Center in the District, as well as the major hospital systems around Baltimore. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome, but they show how we prepare a case and what we are willing to take to a jury.
Types of Objects and Injuries We See in Retained Foreign Body Cases
- Retained sponges and laparotomy pads: The most frequently reported category, usually after abdominal, pelvic, or cesarean procedures where packing is used to control bleeding. A sponge can cause a persistent infection, abscess, or a mass that is mistaken for a tumor.
- Surgical instruments: Clamps, retractors, scissors, and forceps left in a body cavity. These often cause pain and organ damage and may be found only after the patient returns repeatedly with unexplained symptoms.
- Needles and needle fragments: Suture needles can be lost in tissue during closure, particularly in deep or bloody fields. Even a small fragment can migrate or injure a nerve.
- Catheter, wire, and drain fragments: Central line guidewires, drain tubing, and broken device components can be left in blood vessels or tissue after procedures outside the operating room, including ICU and interventional radiology settings.
- Fragments of surgical equipment: Pieces of drills, staplers, or other devices that break during a procedure and are not recovered. These cases may involve a product liability angle in addition to the surgical team’s negligence.
- Delayed-complication injuries: Bowel perforation, fistulas, sepsis, adhesions, and chronic pain that develop as the object remains in place. The longer the delay in detection, the larger the damages picture tends to be.
- Repeat-surgery harm: Complications from the second operation required to remove the object, including scarring, additional organ injury, and anesthesia risks for patients with other health conditions.
What to Do After Learning an Object Was Left Inside You
Get medical care first, and make sure the object is removed by a qualified surgeon. Whatever you feel about the hospital that left it, delaying treatment can turn a manageable problem into a life-threatening one. If you can, ask that the imaging showing the object be preserved and that the removal surgery be documented in detail, including a description of the object, and that the removed item be retained if the facility will allow it.
Request your complete records from both the original surgery and the removal. In these cases, the records that matter most go beyond the operative report to include the nursing intraoperative record, the sponge and instrument count sheets, any notation of a count discrepancy, anesthesia records, and any intraoperative imaging ordered because a count was off. Hospitals often have a protocol requiring an X-ray when counts do not reconcile, and whether that protocol was followed is a central question. Do not sign releases or accept a settlement offer from the hospital’s risk management department or insurer before speaking with a lawyer, because early offers rarely reflect the cost of corrective surgery and long-term complications.
Keep a running record of your symptoms, missed work, pain levels, and out-of-pocket costs. Save every bill and every explanation of benefits. Avoid posting about the incident on social media, since defense lawyers review those accounts.
Where a case is filed depends on where the surgery happened and who the defendants are. A claim over surgery performed in the District is brought in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, Civil Division, which hears civil actions above $10,000, including malpractice. Maryland claims follow a different route. They begin at the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office in Baltimore and, after the parties waive arbitration, move to the circuit court for the county involved, such as the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, Anne Arundel County in Annapolis, Montgomery County in Rockville, or Prince George’s County in Upper Marlboro. Federal court is available only in limited circumstances, such as diversity of citizenship with more than $75,000 at stake.
Proving Negligence When the Object Is the Evidence
Retained object cases are sometimes described as obvious, and in one sense they are: surgical teams are trained to count every sponge, needle, and instrument, and a correct count should leave nothing behind. But a claim still requires proof of a breach of the standard of care and proof that the breach caused compensable harm. A defense lawyer will look for ways to blame the other members of the team, argue that a count was performed properly under unusual circumstances such as an emergency, or contend that the symptoms would have occurred regardless.
The strongest cases are built from the count documentation. Was a count done at the start, before closure of each cavity, and at the end? Did anyone note a discrepancy, and what was done about it? Was the final count signed as correct even though the object was later found? Who was in the room, and were staffing changes or shift handoffs involved during the procedure? Hospitals and surgical centers have written policies on counts and on imaging when counts fail, and a departure from the facility’s own policy is persuasive evidence. We consult surgeons and operating room nursing experts in the relevant specialty to testify about the standard of care for the team as a whole.
Responsibility can extend beyond the surgeon. Depending on the facts, the hospital may be liable for the actions of its nurses and surgical technicians, and a surgeon may share liability for closing despite a missing item. Identifying every responsible party matters because it affects both who pays and how the defense will try to divide blame.
Deadlines, Expert Certificates, and Damages Rules in the District and Maryland
The District of Columbia has no separate malpractice limitations statute. Medical malpractice claims fall under the general three-year period in D.C. Code section 12-301(8), and D.C. applies a discovery rule, which matters a great deal in retained object cases where the patient may not learn of the object until long after the surgery. Even so, it is unwise to wait, and the date a reasonable person would have discovered the problem can be argued. Wrongful death claims in the District must be brought by the personal representative within two years of the death. D.C. malpractice cases also go through court-ordered mediation, to be completed within 30 days of the Initial Scheduling and Settlement Conference, under the Medical Malpractice Proceedings Act. The District does not cap damages in personal injury or malpractice cases.
Maryland is stricter. A claim must be filed within the earlier of five years from the date the injury was committed or three years from the date it was discovered. Filing with the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office counts as filing for that purpose. A claimant generally must file a certificate of a qualified expert within 90 days of the complaint, or the claim is dismissed without prejudice, although the certificate is not required if the defendant does not dispute liability and an extension must be granted for good cause. The expert who signs the certificate cannot be someone who devotes more than 25 percent of professional activities to testifying in personal injury claims. For a child, Maryland courts have held that the time limit for the child’s own claim generally does not begin until the child turns 18, although a parent’s claim for medical expenses can face an earlier deadline.
Maryland also limits noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, in malpractice cases. The limit is tied to the year the injury occurred, rises each January 1, and the jury is not told about it. Economic damages, including medical bills, future care, and lost income, are not capped. Maryland also retains contributory negligence, which can bar recovery entirely if a plaintiff’s own negligence contributed to the harm. In a retained object case, a patient is rarely at fault, but insurers sometimes try to raise it, for example by pointing to missed follow-up appointments.
Frequently Asked Questions About Retained Surgical Object Claims
What counts as a retained surgical object?
Any item that should have been removed from the patient before the operation ended and was not. Sponges, towels, needles, clamps, scissors, retractors, and fragments of devices are all included. The term applies whether the item stays for days or decades.
How would I know if something was left inside me after surgery?
Warning signs include persistent or worsening pain near the surgical site, fever, swelling, drainage from the incision, nausea, bowel changes, or a lump. Imaging such as an X-ray or CT scan usually reveals the object, though sponges can be harder to see than metal instruments on a plain film.
Is a retained object always malpractice?
Not automatically, but leaving an item behind is rarely consistent with the standard of care. Surgical teams are expected to count and account for everything used. Occasionally there are genuine emergencies, such as a patient who is crashing and requires packing that is meant to be removed in a later procedure, and a lawyer has to examine whether that happened and was documented properly.
How long do I have to file in Washington, D.C.?
Malpractice claims fall under the general three-year period, and the District applies a discovery rule. Wrongful death claims must be brought within two years of the death. Because disputes over when a patient should have discovered the problem are common, it is best to have a lawyer review the dates as early as possible.
What if the surgery was in Maryland but I live in D.C.?
The law of the place where the surgery occurred generally drives the claim, so a Maryland operation is subject to Maryland procedures, including the filing process through the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office and the expert certificate requirement. Our firm practices in both jurisdictions and can determine which rules apply.
Do I need an expert before I can file in Maryland?
Yes, in most cases. A certificate from a qualified expert must be filed within 90 days of the complaint, stating that the provider departed from the standard of care and that the departure caused the injury. The certificate can be excused if the defendant does not contest liability, and extensions are available for good cause.
Can I recover if the object was removed quickly and I recovered fully?
Possibly. Even a short-term retention can justify compensation for the added surgery, pain, lost time from work, and medical expenses. The value depends on the harm. Where there was no meaningful injury beyond the removal, the cost of pursuing a claim may be hard to justify, and an honest evaluation should address that.
Will the hospital’s own incident report help my case?
Internal reports and quality review materials are often protected from disclosure, so we cannot count on obtaining them. The count sheets, nursing notes, and imaging that are part of the medical record are usually more useful, and those are available through a records request and, if needed, litigation.
What if the surgeon told me this happens sometimes and offered to cover the cost of removal?
A hospital offer to pay for the corrective surgery does not account for pain, lost income, complications, or future care, and accepting it may come with a release of all claims. Speak with a lawyer before signing anything.
Does a retained object claim change if the patient later developed sepsis or organ damage?
Those complications usually increase the value of a claim, since they add medical costs, recovery time, and long-term effects. Proving that the retained object caused the downstream injury, and not another condition, becomes a key issue and typically requires expert testimony.
Is a retained instrument case worth pursuing if I do not know which surgeon was responsible?
Yes. The operative records identify who was in the room, and the hospital may be responsible for the conduct of its staff even if individual fault is disputed. Identifying the right defendants is part of the investigation.
Will my health insurance pay for treatment while the claim is pending?
Generally yes, and you should use it so that your care is not delayed. Your insurer may have a right of reimbursement from a settlement or verdict, which is addressed when the case resolves.
Serving Retained Surgical Object Clients in Washington, D.C. and Across the Region
We represent patients from every part of the District, including Northwest neighborhoods such as Georgetown, Dupont Circle, Foggy Bottom, Adams Morgan, Columbia Heights, and Cleveland Park, as well as Capitol Hill, Southwest, Navy Yard, Brookland, and communities east of the Anacostia River. Our work extends into neighboring Maryland, where we serve families in Prince George’s County, including Hyattsville, Bowie, College Park, Greenbelt, Laurel, and Upper Marlboro, and in Montgomery County, including Bethesda, Silver Spring, Rockville, and Gaithersburg.
Farther along the corridor, we serve clients in Baltimore City and Baltimore County, including Towson, Dundalk, Catonsville, and Pikesville, and in Annapolis and Anne Arundel County. Whether the surgery took place at a major teaching hospital, a community hospital, or an outpatient surgical center, we investigate where the error occurred and pursue the case in the proper court, whether in the District or in Maryland.
Speak With a Washington DC Retained Surgical Object Lawyer
If a surgeon, hospital, or surgical team left something inside you, a Washington DC retained surgical object lawyer at D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC can review your records, identify what the count sheets and imaging show, and tell you plainly whether you have a claim worth pursuing. There is no fee unless we win, and we advance the costs of the case. Call us for a free case evaluation, any hour of any day, and talk directly with the attorney who will handle your case.
